Uninvited, The (2009)

The Uninvited (click for larger image)Reviewed by Nomad

Starring Emily Browning, Arielle Kebbel, David Strathairn, Elizabeth Banks

Directed by The Guard Brothers

We are no strangers to PG-13 horror. If anything, we pureblood horror fans are veterans of that war-torn landscape. We’ve also cast backward, accusatory glances at the commodity known as the remake. If that remake is from a film of Asian origin, we tighten our eyes like a noose within that glare. “>The Uninvited is guilty of all three perceived offenses out of the gate, but being that it’s PG-13, we can assume the film was not looking for OUR love to begin with. A formulaic commercial screams, “Bring me your children with nothing better to do on a Friday night!!” Little did those children suspect that they may leave with a new nightmare to scar their psyches.

After a horrific accident that claimed her ailing mother, Anna Rydell (Browning) returns home from a stint under psychiatric care to her sister, father, and his new girlfriend who has moved in and made herself at home. Alex (Kebbel), the rebellious sister who spends the majority of the film in a bikini top, is happy to have a partner in crime who will join her in getting under the interloping girlfriend’s skin. After all, it’s only been 10 months since their mother’s death. I suppose some people just mourn … differently. Meanwhile, the girlfriend Rachael (Banks) is making her own bid to woo Anna over to the dark side, sharing awkward moments and inappropriate stories with a girl who only months ago attempted suicide. So where is dad in the middle of this war of wills? It seems he’s more concerned with the release of his new book and screwing his new girlfriend (loudly). Hell of a guy.

Now we’re waiting for the usual black-eyed apparitions to appear and point a bony finger at creepy Rachael groaning “Muuuuurdererrrrrr”, as advertised in the trailer, while we groan back “Seeeeen thissssss befooooore!” But then something magical happens. The scene gets quiet. The very young, innocent looking Anna settles into her bed. A sound in the hall, a jiggle of the door handle. What?! Can it be???? IT’S HORROR!!!!

Like manna from heaven, a chill shoots up my back. I lean forward and the shot goes from tense to terror. I’ll even go so far as to say it is fantastically terrifying. Amazing what a superb actress and a director who understands the basic elements of horror can do with a scene. Astoundingly, the tag team would repeat this feat at least 3 more times. The little girls who enjoy going to these films to pretend they are scared and scream loudly are in for one hell of a shock. These are not raw jump scares. This is the monster that knocks on the door and then waits patiently for you to open it yourself. To quote a song in a brand new context… “Hello, Darkness, my old friend!” We missed you terribly.

The Uninvited (click for larger image)Meanwhile, in between these moments of creep-nirvana, the movie is unfolding like Nancy Drew and the Case of the Twitching Corpse; or maybe you prefer Sisterhood of the Traveling, Bloodthirsty Ghouls. This is a film at odds with itself. Both Browning and Kebbel come off 100% genuine in their roles alongside Elizabeth Banks, who shifts from unsettling to bitchy seamlessly, and the incredible David Strathairn (as Dad) who consistently appears to be barely keeping himself composed amid the chaos. It’s all very refreshing in this type of horror film, or any film for that matter, but these adept actors must double as acrobats, navigating through oddly placed pieces of misinformation and forced plot points that crumble into gaping holes ending in a twist that you won’t see coming but will make you groan at the top of your lungs with utter agony at the cop-out before you.

It almost feels like this movie was created by two separate people. One, a filmmaker seeking to surprise a horror-loving public with a top-notch cast and moments of sheer terror. The other, an inexperienced hack borrowing from the cookie cutter remakes that have marched before him, void of an original thought. One screams for a fresh perspective while the other whines “Come ONN!! I want to be BAAAAD!!!” This film practically FIGHTS to be awful. It’s so perplexing; you may hurt yourself attempting to do the math.

Cinematically, The Uninvited packs in some impressive imagery that will keep you engaged, even while the dialogue suggests you’d be better off sleeping. Teenage boys will be happy to hear they also went to great lengths to get our two teenage (looking) leads as scantly clad as possible, as often as possible, without becoming laughable. Hell, you even get an explosion! If the girls were a little older, had a little dog, and ran around a bit, this could be a Michael Bay film. Creepy fucking spookies are coming!

If you were looking for a straight-up horror film that chases you down those dark corridors the whole time, you’ve come to the wrong haunted house. If you were hoping for an above average PG-13 scarefest (which isn’t saying much), you might be pleasantly surprised. If you had your sights set on perky, underage looking girls following clues left by the dead to catch a seemingly murderous future stepmom and didn’t care how that might pan out — for anyone involved — then you’ve hit paydirt.


2 out of 5

Discuss The Uninvited in Dread Central forums!

Get this site 100% Ad Free Support Us on Patreon!


Get Your Box of Dread Now
*US Residents Only .
  • Cash Bailey

    Hey guys!

    Fuck this pile of shit.

    That is all.

  • krawlingkhaos

    Just to make matters even more confusing isn’t there a different Korean movie (ie not Two Sisters) called “The Uninvited” about two kids on a subway?

    • Uncle Creepy

      Wow. Now my head REALLY hurts.

      • Nomad

        There are no trains in this movie.

  • Mr. Dark

    I second the call for a compare/contrast with the original. I have no interest in seeing this, as I generally boycott -all- US remakes of Asian horror after being burned about 6 movies in a row, but I am curious as to whether they actually stuck to the plot of the original or if they spun off and did their own thing?

    Mr. Dark
    Part-Time Dread Central Gaming Guy
    Full-Time Freelance Smartass

    • Nomad

      Well give me a breakdown of the story elements and moment from Tale and I’ll tell you how close the new one comes.

  • Sirand

    I’d love to see a review done by a fan of “A Tale of Two Sisters” who could do an original/remake comparison.

  • G.D.

    I don’t know if this will clarify or not, because it’s really an odd movie. It has so many good elements, but the sum is less than the parts. The acting is uniformly terrific, there are a few really good creepy moments and a decent jump-scare. But in the end, it’s just…not that good. The plotting is decent, though the dialogue can be pretty awful, though the acting is good enough that the dialogue doesn’t come off as bad as it could.

    Overall, I wouldn’t recommend it for seeing in a theatre (especially one populated with shitty little 13-14 year olds) but I think it could probably work pretty well on DVD in a darkened room by yourself.

    • Nomad

      haha..see? GD basically said the same thing i said. I’m telling you, this movie was striving to be PG13 dreck but the superior acting and above average creeps kept pulling it back. It was like a tug of war that no one was winning, so they both gave up and compromised on an ending we’ve seen far too often lately that you are sure to get annoyed over.

      nuff said?

      • doubleh55

        Thanks for clarifying. Awesome.

  • doubleh55

    You know how you can vote on Amazon and other places on whether or not a review is helpful? This review wasn’t very helpful. I read it twice and I need a clarification. Is this movie good or not?