Doctor Gash’s Top 10 Greatest Horror Movies… EVER! #9 – The Blair Witch Project

Post Thumb:


Perhaps the most polarizing film on Doctor Gash’s Top 10 Greatest Horror Movies…Ever! list is Number 9, The Blair Witch Project. I’ve heard many people talk about how they detested this film, that nothing happened, that it was a waste of time.

Not only is The Blair Witch Project undeserving of these criticisms, it was one of the most influential and profitable films of its time.

#9-The Blair Witch Project
“I’m afraid to close my eyes, I’m afraid to open them.”

Those that criticize the movie certainly missed the point of the effort, but regardless of any negativity, the box office take was staggering. Made on a budget that would barely cover a decent bachelor party in Vegas, Blair Witch ended up bringing in nearly $250,000,000. Not a bad return on your investment. In addition to the earnings, it solidified the found footage sub-genre of horror, and, most impressive of all, The Blair Witch Project was launched with a groundbreaking viral marketing campaign that was so effective it had many people thinking the whole thing was real.

Doctor Gash's Top 10 Greatest Horror Movies... EVER! #9 - The Blair Witch Project

Much like the Number 10 film on this list, Scream, The Blair Witch Project does not earn its spot here solely on the content of the film. Scream made the top 10 for being a great film at the perfect time. The Blair Witch Project makes the list primarily for the fact that its guerilla advertising campaign turned the world of film marketing completely upside down and reshaped the entire business of selling movies.

The brilliant marketing campaign, spearheaded by Artisan studio executive Steven Rothenberg, included a Sci-Fi (not yet Syfy) Network mockumentary about the missing filmmakers entitled “The Curse of the Blair Witch”. The program even included interviews with the “parents” of the missing kids, and it aired just before the release of the film. An internet buzz about the movie possibly being real police footage stoked The Blair Witch Project and had audiences completely intrigued from the start. Blair Witch used the internet as no one in Hollywood had before and by doing so left audiences ravenous to see the film. It’s a marketing strategy that is envied and copied relentlessly to this day.

And the trailblazing of The Blair Witch Project did not stop with its marketing campaign; it only began there. Creators/directors Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sanchez solidified an entire sub-genre of horror, the found footage style. This wasn’t the first film to use the idea of found footage as Ruggero Deodato’s Cannibal Holocaust used the same technique in 1980, and there were a few movies scattered between then and The Blair Witch Projectthat tried it, but it never really took off. After the success of Blair Witch we’ve seen an endless parade of movies that use this technique, and some do it well. Just a brief glance of the found footage film list reveals offerings such as the Paranormal Activity series, Cloverfield, The Last Exorcism, [REC] and [REC]2 and (here’s one for you) August Underground’s Mordum. An entirely new technique of filmmaking was embraced after Blair Witch which was not only fresh to audiences, but allowed films to be made much less expensively, giving more moviemakers a chance to bring their stories to life.

After the great marketing and creative presentation, what do we have? We have a film that is a study in tension. The best horror films give you a balance of tension and payoff. You have your build-up scenes and then your payoff scenes. A few minutes of walking through a strange dark house is paid off by a killer jumping from the closet and doing nasty things. Blair Witch was very adept at creating the tension, but they never gave the payoff…and it didn’t matter. The movie taught us that great horror wasn’t about seeing the gruesome monster or the knife plunging directly into the victim. It taught us that the journey was just as important as the money shot. If not more so. The Blair Witch Project was so tense with its creepy sounds and strange occurrences that you’re cringing in your seat waiting for something to happen during your first viewing. Well, spoiler alert, nothing really does happen, but does that mean you were never cringing? No sir. The Blair Witch Project scared us, it scared the crap out of us, but people rail against it because it never showed the antagonist. Would it have been scarier if we eventually saw what was making all the crazy noises and toying with the filmmakers? Not at all. No filmmaker can create something scarier than we can conjure in our own minds. Only we as individuals know our own deepest, darkest fears, and this is what we use to fill in the blanks for The Blair Witch Project.

Overall, the film is amazing. As our characters are lost in the woods, it has an incredibly claustrophobic feel even though they are in the wilderness and completely unencumbered. Stephen King has proven time and again that being trapped is the most horrific scenario one can find himself in. He’s used the idea repeatedly in books like Misery, Cujo and Gerald’s Game. And in reality, if a character isn’t trapped on some level, can you really have a horror story? Our three young filmmakers are trapped, unable to find their way back to the car. They walk south all day and end up right back where they started and hunker down for another night of strange noises and freaky happenings. Welcome to the world of the Blair Witch.

The Blair Witch Project is basically an improvised piece of work, adding to the authentic feel of it. Myrick and Sanchez really challenged the actors physically during filming (rationing food, keeping them in the elements) to enhance the tension. It worked. Their ad-libbed dialogue felt real. It all worked so perfectly.

Although it has its critics, The Blair Witch Project was groundbreaking not only for its unique filming style, but for its brilliant marketing campaign that has been, and will be, copied for years to come. The movie was masterful at building tension, so much so that it never had to give the money shot. Audiences were uncomfortable enough with the tortures of the woods that no further aggravation was required. However, when we finally get to the basement of Rustin Parr’s cabin and Mike is standing in the corner of the cellar, an iconic horror image is created. For ’90s horror, this final shot was your moon landing, your Zapruder film. It’s the culmination of a perfectly original horror experience. An amazing ending for a groundbreaking film.

The Blair Witch Project

Got news? Click here to submit it!
Be part of the project in the comments section below!

Image Type 1:

Get this site 100% Ad Free Support Us on Patreon!

Scott Hallam

We all go a little mad sometimes...haven't you?

Get Your Box of Dread Now
*US Residents Only .
  • Doctor Gash

    Sounds like we’ve got a winner here! I know it’s a very controversial entry on the list and I’m glad you guys were open-minded enough to hear me out on it. Can’t wait to hear what you have to say about #8. This is fun!

  • LSD Zombie

    I’ve come to realize that the most influential films tend to be the ones that are most often lampooned. Everyone loves making fun of the snot scene with Heather. What’s great about Blair Witch Project is that it capitalizes on a fear that is not often explored; the fear of being lost in a foreign environment. To make matters worse, not only are they lost, but they’re being fucked with by a supernatural force. Prior to it’s release, there had been nothing like it. And every found footage film since then owes Blair Witch a debt of gratitude. I think it belongs exactly where it is on this list.

  • Jinx

    Another great choice, another great article.

    Can’t wait to see where this list goes.

  • Terminal

    Is this a personal top 10? I mean no way is Scream one of the greatest horror movies ever made, subjective or not.

    • Doctor Gash

      I guess you would have to consider it a personal top 10…any top 10 list is, right? Unless it’s generated by some kind of poll or in some other way where multiple people could vote on their top films (hmm…maybe that’s a feature I should work on. I’m sure all you guys would love to have your say on the top films).

      But yeah, Terminal, I think you’d have to say it’s a personal top 10 because I’m certainly not speaking for anyone else here on the site. And I’m sure if we polled all the writers (and readers) for their personal top 10 lists, we’d get a different answer from everyone. I just weighed several factors like how scary, entertainment value, influence on other films, rewatchability…and came up with a list that I thought could stand up as the Top 10. Everyone’s is going to be different…I’m lucky enough to have a forum here where I can at least give my explanation as to why I feel each film deserves inclusion. And to be total honest with you, I’m having a friggin’ blast with you guys as we go through this…and we’re only on #9!

      • Terminal

        Gotcha. Just a question. No offense intended.

        • Doctor Gash

          No offense taken, sir. I appreciate the question. Thanks much.

        • Hakk Wylde

          Bwahaha! You need to change your screen name to “Tormentor”, Terminal. You have way too much fun…provoking. HAHA! Awesome. 😀

          • Terminal

            Oh come on. I was being sincere. I am a fan of Gash’s articles.

          • Hakk Wylde

            Oh, I know! And a quite clever one at that. I like how you get him to express more about the reasoning behind his picks. 🙂

          • Jinx

            Much like you cleverly drew more of an explanation out of Terminal for his initial post.

            …well played, Wylde. Well played.

          • Hakk Wylde

            Haha! You guys are Awesome. \m/

          • Terminal

            Okay, now I’m having fun, lol. Please tell me more about the glory of me.

  • Foywonder

    Maybe this should be billed as a list of the most “influential” horror movie of all times because while both Scream and Blair Witch both rank amongst the most influential of modern times I don’t think either are anywhere near the top ten greatest horror movies of all time.

    • Doctor Gash

      I definitely tried to combine the films’ quality and influence to come up with some kind of ranking for them. And believe me, numbers 9 and 10 were really tough to nail down. These will certainly be the ones most debated, as you can see already by the comments here and on the FB page. But regardless of where you stand on Scream and Blair Witch as 9 and 10, hang in there, we’ve got some real heavy hitters coming up that hopefully everyone will agree with.

      • Gus Bjork

        I think ‘greatest’ is a good choice rather than ‘best’. I was thinking along the same lines as Foy after reading your #9 piece but then figured there’s many horror films that have influence but aren’t very good (I don’t know why but Hershel Gordon Lewis came to mind). Conversely, ‘best’ will be completely subjective to whoever makes the list.

        I completely agree on Blair Witch being on the list by the way and, depending on what you have waiting, it’s ranking. It was more or less original and kept a slow burn build and ended exactly how it should have. I understand how someone would be disappointed by it after it’s hyping though (I saw it first day in limited release after Sundance thankfully)

  • doubleh55

    No, it’s TOTALLY deserving all the criticism it gets because it is a boring and horribly made movie. It was all marketing. Without the marketing, nobody would ever care about this wretched movie. I remember when I first saw it and it gets to the last scene I was completely confused until somebody explained it to me. I realized that the movie was so boring from the word go that I completely missed the explanation.

    There are 10 horror movies from 70s that are better than this movie.

  • Terminal

    Great pick. Loved this movie then and love it now. The first time I saw it it was so fucking intense.

  • MonsterMash

    I really like this movie. Good pick.