My Amityville Horror (2012)

Cover art:


My Amityville Horror (2012)Starring Daniel Lutz, Lorraine Warren, Laura DiDio, Marvin Scott

Directed by Eric Walter

Sadly, when most of us think about the horrific crimes and arcane supernatural occurrences that happened in 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York, swarms of flies, boo scares and gratuitous shots of Ryan Reynolds’ abs come to mind. Due to the book The Amityville Horror written by Jay Anson, the film adaptation and its many inferior sequels, we rarely remember that this unsettling phenomenon was actually experienced by the unfortunate Lutz family when they fled the infamous house in 1975 only 28 days after moving in.

37 years later, director Eric Walter had the incredible chance to interview Daniel Lutz, a family member who was left traumatized after the unexplained events that happened when he was eight years old, and his experience has clearly taken a toll on him to this very day.

In the documentary Lutz speaks candidly of what it was like to live in the house, his absolute hatred for his late stepfather, George Lutz, and his interpretation of the horrifying memories he experienced, which unfortunately loses credibility the more defensive and angry Lutz becomes while being interviewed.

Fantasia 2012 ReviewFor the uninitiated My Amityville Horror proves to be an intriguing and concise character study; however, those expecting to see a frightening documentary exposing all the unheard horrors of 112 Ocean Avenue will be slightly disappointed as Walter’s goal is to critically observe and dissect Lutz’s psychological profile and behavior rather than further exploit the details of the hauntings any more than they already have been.

At first the documentary does provide some details to fulfill the viewers’ morbid curiosity by recalling the family massacre committed by Ronald DeFeo in the house on November 13, 1974, and when Lutz actually does open up about being possessed by a spirit, it immediately sends chills up everybody’s spines. Alas, when Lutz starts blaming his stepfather’s love for the occult for what happened, verbally attacking the director for his agnostic views on camera and refuses to take a lie detector test, it can be argued that dissecting Daniel Lutz is more deeply disturbing than the Amityville horror itself.

Throughout the documentary Lutz is teamed up with Laura DiDio, the loyal investigative reporter who interviewed Lutz as a child, and then Lorraine Warren, the eerie demonologist who investigated the Amityville house in 1976 and is well known to others as a fraud off camera. Although they both share strong personalities, rarely do they offer an unbiased opinion for the viewers to question, making the audience members that more skeptical of Lutz’s accounts.

While watching My Amityville Horror unfold, it may frustrate viewers as more questions are asked than answered, but it examines the frailty of human perception in such a brilliant way that you will be thinking about Daniel Lutz’s story long after the creepy end credits have rolled.

4 out of 5

Discuss My Amityville Horror in the comments section below!

Get this site 100% Ad Free Support Us on Patreon!

Serena Whitney

Get Your Box of Dread Now
*US Residents Only .
  • Mr. Dark

    Whoa, HUGE slam on Lorraine Warren out of nowhere. Well known as a fraud? So much for objective journalism. The Warrens are -very- well respected in their community of paranormal research. What’s well known is Lorraine’s tendency to go off in the weeds since Ed’s sensible guiding hand is no longer with us to keep her from flights of fancy. Still, wow, massive slam on an old lady with a lengthy history of helping people.

    • Uncle Creepy

      Don’t think it was a slam by Serena. The sad fact is in the paranormal world a lot of folks consider her to be a bit less than reliable.

  • Sirand

    I’m very agnostic on the subject of Amityville (all the debunkers and “mediums” are CRAZY). The DeFeo murders are still the creepiest unexplained part of that story. As for the Lutzes, only they know for sure…but George & Kathy stuck with their story till the day they died.

    That said, I have little interest in watching a documentary about some born-again nut who believes his father’s transcendental meditation was what opened up a rift to the demonic world. Cuckoo!!!

  • Jezzerat

    “…we rarely remember that this unsettling phenomenon was actually experienced by the unfortunate Lutz family when they fled the infamous house in 1975 only 28 days after moving in.”

    That’s because it wasn’t actually experienced by anyone. The only “unsettling phenomena” the Lutzes encountered was an overflowing bill pile from buying a money pit they couldn’t afford. The “Amityville Horror” has been debunked a thousand times.

  • The Woman In Black

    Great review! Daniel Lutz is super intense and compelling, but yeah, once he started in on George’s “obsession” with the occult and telekinetic “powers”, he lost me a bit. I wanted to hear more about his “possession”, abandonment by his mom, and time spent with the priests who beat him regularly in an attempt at exorcism. If that stuff can be verified, then a Part 2 to this documentary would definitely be welcome.