Innkeepers, The (Blu-ray / DVD)

Cover art:


The InnkeepersStarring Sara Paxton, Pat Healy, Kelly McGillis, George Riddle

Directed by Ti West

Distributed by Dark Sky Films

It’s unfortunate that, unlike in an era such as the 70s, we no longer have much in the way of slow-burn horror cinema. Even with a contemporary film that has more on its mind than being a kill-a-minute slash-a-thon (not that there’s anything wrong with those), there will inevitably be, at the very least, an opening sequence of mayhem to set the stage for the rest of the horror to eventually come. It’s all too rare to find a flick willing to just take its time with its characters before diving into full-on genre territory.

We’re lucky to still have movies that even attempt this, such as last year’s Insidious and the ridiculously successful Paranormal Activity films. However, we’re luckier still to have a filmmaker like Ti West on our side.

West, who found success with his previous The House of the Devil, has made his best film to date with the charming, character-driven comedy spookfest The Innkeepers. Featuring a great cast and a perfect location, The Innkeepers concerns a pair of paranormal enthusiasts (Healy and Paxton) who work at the purportedly haunted, and soon-to-be-closed, Yankee Pedlar Inn.

Taking advantage of the mostly empty space, and having an almost entire lack of customers to contend with, the two attempt to find some (any!) sort of evidence of the supernatural, with a little help from one of their tenants (washed-up actress/faith healer Leanne Rease-Jones, played with a perfect mix of world-weariness and venom by Kelly McGillis). Laughs and shivers ensue.

I applaud West for having no fear when it comes to his deliberately paced storytelling, both with this film and The House of the Devil. He allows the story to linger on his characters, sticking with them for long enough stretches that we almost forget what genre we’re in, even while slowly building up the tension before its inevitable release. I applaud him further for making his leads so damned likeable (helped in no small part by the performances), so much so that I’d have been happy following the two throughout a story with no supernatural or horror elements whatsoever.

Warning! Mild Spoilers Ahead!
If I have any problem with the film, it’s the final act. While the climax that we’re given is certainly hair-raising, it feels rather truncated. I’d have been happier with, if not a more elaborate chase sequence, then perhaps a somewhat longer one at the very least. And while my hat’s off to West for not shying away from a dark finale, I wonder if he chose the right one. Considering how light and fun the preceding eighty minutes had been, the ending is more than a little sobering. Imagine watching a version of Ghostbusters where Peter Venkman dies at the end. West’s choice of mood for this ending was undoubtedly deliberate, but appropriate? I’m not sure.
End Spoilers

Still, I’m calling The Innkeepers a must-see for fans who like their horror a bit on the quiet, shivery side, and served with a helping of chuckles. For more on the film, check out Drew Tinnin’s review here.

Dark Sky has put together a nice package for the Blu-ray release of the film. The image is sharp, with inky blacks that perfectly represent West’s shadow-laden photography. The audio is a joy, too, full of unsettling noises both big and small. Oh, and it’s meant to be played LOUD (as a note preceding the film tells us), which will likely have you jumping out of your skin at the various boos! sprinkled throughout the feature.

The bonus features aren’t too skimpy, either. Dark Sky gives us two audio commentaries, a featurette, and a trailer. The commentaries (one with West and the producers, the other with West, Paxton and Healy) are both solid, though the director/cast commentary is certainly the more enjoyable of the two. Still, those with an interest in the nuts and bolts of indie filmmaking should find both to be must-listens.

The featurette is fun, if all too brief. One wishes that a far longer doc could’ve been produced, but so it goes. Rounding out the features is the theatrical trailer, which is…uh, a good trailer. As trailers go.

If you’re a fan of West’s, or of smart, creepy horror in general, you need this film for your collection. Skip the exploratory rental fee and just pick up the Blu-ray already. The Yankee Pedlar Inn eagerly awaits your arrival.

Special Features:

  • Audio Commentary with Writer/Director/Editor Ti West, Producers Peter Phok and Larry Fessenden, and Second-Unit Director/Sound Designer Graham Reznick
  • Audio Commentary with Ti West and Stars Sara Paxton and Pat Healy
  • The Innkeepers: Behind the Scenes featurette
  • Trailer


    4 out of 5

    Special Features:

    3 out of 5

    Discuss The Innkeepers in the comments section below.

    Get this site 100% Ad Free Support Us on Patreon!
  • Jinx

    Get Your Box of Dread Now
    *US Residents Only .
    • kiddcapone

      You know, I’m really getting sick of reading the over-used phrase “slow-burn horror” and using it to really mean some people are too short-minded to appreciate it. That is simply not true.

      Just letting something simmer for 70 minutes doesn’t mean jackshit if the end payoff isn’t worth the journey. It has to GO somewhere that leaves you awestruck and clubbed over the head. Something to pack a punch. The Innkeepers fails miserably in the end. For the 1st two-thirds, I loved the movie. The two lead characters were amazing. I was actually, for once, impressed with Ti West. Until now, I always thought the guy really sucked ass. But this time around, he created an interesting story, awesome location, excellent dialogue, gave some honest-to-god hair-raising suspenseful moments, and then….like everything this guy touches, it just fizzles out like a dud firework.

      The Innkeepers is a truly frustrating infuriating experience. All the ingredients to be something GREAT, memorable, fascinating, and stand-out in a sea of mediocre horror films WAS there. It just needed a better chef in the kitchen to put it all together, and unfortunately Ti West sucks at cooking. You can see glimpses of potential in everything the guy does, yet he continues to underachieve and can’t seem to figure it out. I have my doubts if he ever will…

      The Innkeepers 2/5.

    • Vanvance1

      I really wanted to like this film. The acting and characters are solid and believable but the horror aspects never really get off the ground. I’m fine with a slow burn but at some point there has to be a payoff. What we get for a conclussion feels forced and unsatisfying.

      2.5 knives for me.

    • nonserviam03

      I need to pick this up, I REALLY liked this one.