Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark (2011)

Don't Be Afraid of the Dark (2011)Starring Katie Holmes, Guy Pearce, Bailee Madison

Directed by Troy Nixey

I’ve always felt sorry for filmmakers like Henry Selick whose credentials tend to get overshadowed by their more famous, higher-billed producers (to this day, I still have to remind people that Tim Burton didn’t direct The Nightmare Before Christmas). We saw the same thing happen last year when John Dowdle’s Devil got confused as the next M. Night Shyamalan film by the public at large.

Since Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark arrives with Guillermo Del Toro’s name plastered all over it, we’ll no doubt see the same thing, but at least in this case it’s a little more earned. Del Toro (who wrote and produced) takes on a much more active role than previous produced flicks like The Orphanage, and his fingerprints are visible in every frame of this film.

That’s not to take anything away from director Troy Nixey, who crafts a cool Gothic spin on the 1973 TV movie of the same name. The story opens as little Sally Hirst (Bailee Madison) is sent off (i.e., ditched) by her mother to Rhode Island to live with her father (Guy Pierce) and his new girlfriend (Katie Holmes), who are remodeling the world’s creepiest mansion for architectural fame and fortune. No sooner does Sally settle in to her new dysfunctional family life when a horde of small creatures emerge from below the house and start beckoning her to the basement. When she doesn’t comply, Sally quickly becomes the target of the malevolent little hell spawn and must fend for herself – cause adults, as we all know, are dismissive assholes.

While it may not have the same punch as Del Toro’s Spanish-language films, the script is full of his usual ideas and themes. Changing the Sally character (an adult in the TV movie) to a little girl adds an extra level of innocence and vulnerability to the story, and actress Bailee Madison delivers one of the most intense performances you’ll ever see from a child actress, single-handedly blowing away all her adult co-stars. Troy Nixey’s direction is full of suitably dark visuals and lavish production design, and he manages to pull sympathetic moments from every member of the cast (even the ever-wooden Holmes). Make no mistake; this is a creature feature, but it’s the story’s family dynamic that makes it rise above the more conventional elements.

The creatures themselves are all CG creations but look pretty damn great (especially since they’re mostly confined to the shadows) and are better than the admittedly dated shrunken actors and latex masks in the original movie. But while they’re menacing creations, the major strike against Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark is that it isn’t very effective as an outright scary horror film. Rather it’s much more of a traditional dark fairy tale, like Pan’s Labyrinth crossed with Gremlins. And aside from a grisly opening sequence, it’s a bit perplexing that the MPAA slapped this one with an R rating.

Despite feeling a bit familiar, Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark is an expertly paced Gothic chiller that rises above most big-screen studio features thanks to the skill and enthusiasm of its crew and cast. It won’t do much to enhance your fear when the lights go out, but it’s a straightforward classical story well told.

4 out of 5

Discuss Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark in the space below!

Get Your Box of Dread Now
*US Residents Only .

Steve Barton

You're such an inspiration for the ways that I will never, ever choose to be.

  • nazo

    I really liked the first half of the movie-the atmosphere was there, I liked the idea of (minor spoiler) the dad’s girlfriend who doesn’t want a child becoming the closest thing to a real parent, and I liked the “look” of everything. (I’m a big Del Toro fan, which doesn’t hurt). But I thought the movie started to come apart beginning with the psychiatrist scene. After that, and the next few scenes, by the time they get back to the house the atmosphere is gone, the backstory/exposition is needless and makes the ending less exciting, and it becomes an Idiot Movie in places. It was still decent overall, but definitely a missed opportunity.

  • Uncle Creepy

    Yeah, not a big fan. The characters were forgettable and did every stupid thing that you could imagine to keep the plot going. Ie: Bathroom scene. Don’t wanna turn the light on that’s two feet away from you? How about raising the blinds in the window behind you. Sigh.

  • DavidFullam

    This must have really broken the 4th wall!

  • nonserviam03

    This is looking good. I’m excited.

  • LSD Zombie

    Shit, I’ll see anything that involved Del Toro in some capacity.

  • Cinemascribe

    Thanks for saving me a trip to the cinema. With ticket prices being what they are these days, if I don’t think a horror flick is going to seriously bring the scary, I save it for DVD. Not to say this sounds like a bad flick..it doesn’t.But I think I’ll be fine watching this one at home and saving a few bucks.

    Do you wanna party? It’s PARTYTIME.

    • Sirand

      If you don’t support it, don’t complain when The Roommate 2 hits theaters next year.

  • Terminal

    Really Good review, Andrew. Can’t wait.
    “We are bad guys. That means we’ve got more to do other than bullying companies. It’s fun to lead a bad man’s life.”