Fourth Kind, The (2009)

The Fourth KindReviewed by Buz “Danger” Wallick

Starring Milla Jovovich, Will Patton, Hakeem Kae-Kazim, Corey Johnson, Elias Koteas

Directed by Olatunde Osunsanmi

In the 1970’s a scale of measurement was established for alien encounters. The First Kind is a UFO sighting, an encounter of the Second Kind is when evidence is collected, and when contact is made with extraterrestrials, it is called an encounter of the Third Kind. An encounter of the Fourth Kind involves abduction and thus is what the film The Fourth Kind is about.

The story follows the supposedly true and disturbing story of Dr. Abigail Tyler (portrayed by Milla Jovovich), a psychologist in Nome, Alaska, who begins to notice some similarities between her patients’ symptoms. It seems they all have the same exact recurring dream: They wake up in the middle of the night and see an owl perched in front of their bedroom window, staring at them.

Just writing that sends a shiver down my spine. I’m going to try and keep this review as spoiler free as I can so as to not give away any surprises, but first let me just say this is an amazingly unique, well crafted film from beginning to end.

The Fourth Kind opens with Jovovich telling us that the movie we are about to watch is all based on true documented events. The narrative is split up among a sit-down interview with the real Dr. Tyler and director Olatunde Osunsanmi, film reenactments, and archive footage. And honestly, the archive footage is more terrifying than anything they shot for the film.

The Fourth KindFirst-time director Olatunde Osunsanmi and his director of photography Lorenzo Senatore put together a beautifully shot film. The cinematography in this flick is breathtaking at times, particularly the wide aerial photography of the Alaskan terrain. Absolutely gorgeous stuff.

The editing between “real” footage and the film is done very well, though at times it is a little jarring. But when they show you side-by-side panels of the real footage with the film, you can’t take your eyes off the screen.

Speaking of which, let’s discuss the archive footage. Now I can’t say for certain if all this stuff is real or fake, so I won’t say any more. What I will say, though, is that fake or not, the “real” footage packs enough punch to chill you to the bone. There are things that happen in the film that is absolutely disturbing just to hear about, let alone see footage of. Then again, there’s some stuff they show that is supposed to be “actual” footage that’s really hard not to call shenanigans on. If everything they showed in the movie was indeed “real”, then The Fourth Kind just proved the existence of aliens and that it’s medically possible for people’s mouths to open wider than their heads. Either way, it’s fucking scary.

As far as the performances go, Milla Jovovich is excellent as the widowed Tyler. She is able to play a grieving mother trying to raise her children and a determined doctor trying to figure out what’s going on simultaneously. Elias Koteas and Will Patton turn in great supporting roles as well, and Hakeem Kae Kazim as the Somalian history expert is awesome.

Overall, I dug the hell out of The Fourth Kind. While it does get a little ridiculous and over-the-top at times, it’s a well crafted docu-drama-esque film that takes itself seriously, builds tension, and scares the shit out of you through and through. Whether it’s true or fake, really isn’t the point. If it’s true, then holy shit! We’re all going to die from alien abductions in the near future. If it’s fake, then the filmmakers figured out a brilliant and original way to scare audiences, and the actors touted to be real people deserve Oscars.

And a piece of advice for everyone reading this: If you ever see an owl staring at you through your bedroom window, shoot that motherfucker in the face.

4 out of 5

Ready to decide for yourselves if it’s real or fake?
Buy your The Fourth Kind tickets in advance at

Discuss The Fourth Kind in our forums!

Get this site 100% Ad Free Support Us on Patreon!

Buz Wallick

Get Your Box of Dread Now
*US Residents Only .
  • FleshyHeadedMutant

    My wife wanted to see this & we had a free ticket , so we just got back. We both hated it . The only way I could see someone finding this movie remotely scary/entertaining, is if they believed that the “actual” footage is legit. As my wife & I both have IQs over 20 …. we didnt . Thats fine as long as the filmmakers are competent enough to deliver a decent film ….they didnt . My question is : If you are going to fake “actual” footage in a supposedly scary film, wouldnt you do even more to try to spook the audience ? Believe it or not ,this film is a dud .

    • The Buz

      And if they went too over the top, it’d lose it’s sense of realism. Who cares if it’s fake. Blair Witch is fake, Cloverfield is fake, Paranormal Activity is fake. Yet those are all good movies.

      And having an IQ above 20 is not an extraordinary feat. Now if you’re IQ was above 95 then we’re getting some where. 😉

      • LifeMi

        I have to disagree with you, Buz. The Fourth Kind was absolute garbage; I was bored out of my mind and thought the integration of the real footage was annoying. Furthermore, it was probably the most overdirected film I’ve seen since I’ll Always Know What You Did Last Summer. The only positives I’ll give it are Elias Koteas, the owl closeups and the “real” Abigail Tyler. Other than that, a complete waste of time and potential.

        • The Buz

          And you’re totally welcome to disagree. Appreciate your thoughts!

          • LifeMi

            Here’s the biggest question I had about The Fourth Kind: was it just me or did the real Abigail Tyler look like an owl with her eyes all bugged out? I’m curious, because that was the only aspect of the film even remotely creepy.

      • FleshyHeadedMutant

        You are correct , it doesnt matter if its real or fake , a shitty movie is a shitty movie either way .

  • valdamirie

    9/10 easy!!!

    i just got home from watching forth kind and i cant go to sleep. im afraid im gonna be abducted by aliens and taken to a space ship and do shit to me up my ass and then clean my memory and remember nothing but a sore butt. this movie is worth every penny @ $10 a pease for me and my fiance who right now is very pissed at me for doing research on this movie rather than fall sleep.

  • Barfneck

    Won’t be wasting anymore money on the paranormal. Already blew $20 this year on Paranormal Activity which was complete garbage. They’re not getting me again.

    • The Buz

      This isn’t about the paranormal. Well, at least is has nothing to do with ghosts or demons.

    • DavidFullam

      “Paranormal Activity which was complete garbage.”

      I like your ideas and wish to subscribe to your newsletter.

  • Floydian Trip

    I really can’t wait now. This is at least going to be thought provoking I think.

  • BoggyCreekBeast

    Dang, I was going to see The Men Who Stare at Goats this weekend, but the above review has me thinking twice about that in favor of this one. Haven’t seen a decent movie in this sub-genre since Fire in the Sky. Decisions, decisions…