AVP Lawsuit Comes to End for Writer

Source Name:

The Hollywood Reporter

Source Url:


Post Thumb:


And today’s lesson … Sometimes it’s better to leave well enough alone. Or at least make damn sure you’re in the right! In case you didn’t know, a writer has been in litigation with 20th Century Fox, accusing the studio of stealing his script for Alien vs. Predator. Why anyone would want to put his name on that mess is beyond us, but in any event the verdict is in …

As per The Hollywood Reporter:

In another sign that Hollywood studios are willing to go to the mat against writers who dare claim to have their ideas stolen, 20th Century Fox has won $40,000 in attorneys’ fees from a writer who sued the studio in 2009 over Alien vs. Predator.

James Muller, who is now claiming insolvency, had alleged his script, titled The Lost Continent, bore striking resemblance to 2004’s Alien vs. Predator. Both screenplays told the story of a battle between extraterrestrial creatures, but the surface similarity wasn’t very convincing for U.S. District Judge Denny Chin.

In an order granting Fox’s motion for attorneys’ fees, Judge Chin gives three reasons why Muller’s claims were “frivolous and objectively unreasonable.”

First, the stories were really different. The Lost Continent was about “a government-led expedition to the Antarctic to investigate a mysterious structure below the frozen surface. Second, the alleged similarities were ill-conceived. Muller tried to demonstrate “2000+ similarities”, but many of the pairings were found to be not very similar. Third and finally, to the extent there was similarities, Judge Chin found they were unprotectable. Many were stock themes instead of things one can actually copyright — expression.

Fox then went after Muller to send a message to potential plaintiffs. The $40,000 award of attorneys’ fees continues a recent trend where studios fight back hard.

The judge’s order on Monday also reveals the amount of billable hours a studio can spend in fighting a copyright infringement claim. According to papers submitted by Fox in the case, its fees were based on 1,230.3 hours worked by its team at Hogan & Hartson at rates ranging from $165 to $395 per hour.

That works out to more than $300,000 to fight a nuisance case, but Fox only requested $150,000 with the “belief that the lesser award (would) adequately serve the statutory goals of compensation and deterrence,” which the judge seems to have been open to accepting but for a look at Muller’s tax returns.

Seeing that the plaintiff really was financially hard-up, the judge settles on $40,000 as an amount that will do the trick of sending a message without ruining the guy financially.

AVP Lawsuit Comes to End for Writer

Got news? Click here to submit it!
Sue someone in the comments section below!
Image Type 1:

DreadCentral presents Box of Dread

Box of Dread
* US Residents Only
  • Screamz

    ^^Agreed. And I also like Creepy’s comment about why anyone would want their name associated with that piece of crap. If anything, I’d sue to have my name REMOVED from the film…

  • Vanvance1

    This is the very tip of the iceberg. In the US there are countless worthless, despicable lawsuits started every day.

    Lawyers should be fined for filing lawsuits without any merit. BIG fines.

Steve Barton

You're such an inspiration for the ways that I will never, ever choose to be.