Joaquin Phoenix to Portray Edgar Allan Poe?

Joaquin Phoenix to Portray Edgar Allan Poe?Thanks to the power of the Internet, news now comes to us from a wide variety of sources from the trades to Facebook to Twitter to such faraway places as the India Times, according to which Joaquin Phoenix will be portraying Edgar Allan Poe in an adaptation of the book The Beautiful Cigar Girl.

India Times got the story from Oscar-winning sound recordist Resul Pookutty (Slumdog Millionaire) that he’s been hired to recreate the sound textures of New York in 1854. It’s an adaptation of The Beautiful Cigar Girl by Daniel Stashower and based on an eerie real-life experience of author Edgar Allan Poe which happened just months before his death.

From comes this summary of Stashower’s novel: In July 1841, Mary Rogers, a beautiful young New York cigar clerk, was strangled and her body tossed in the Hudson River, a crime so ghastly that it pitted the city’s sensational tabloids against each other in a contest of rumor and speculation. Due to a bungled investigation from start to finish, the murder appealed enough to Edgar Allan Poe that he co-opted it for ‘The Mystery of Marie Rogêt’. Knocking back and forth between the unending case and Poe’s utterly depressing life cycle of debt, poverty, and alcoholism, Daniel Stashower’s ‘Cigar Girl’ takes a solidly comprehensive look at the predecessor to today’s all-too-common media crime frenzies.

Aside from Phoenix as Poe, no other details were made available, but as soon as we hear more, we’ll be sure to share.

Uncle Creepy

Got news? Click here to submit it!
Come out of retirement in the Dread Central forums!

Image Type 1:

Get this site 100% Ad Free Support Us on Patreon!

Steve Barton

You're such an inspiration for the ways that I will never, ever choose to be.

Get Your Box of Dread Now
*US Residents Only .
  • Floydian Trip

    I like Joaquin he’s been in some excellent movies. Except for The Village, that was an abomination but not even Jack could’ve saved that one. I don’t know what Edgar Allan Poe is supposed to be like.

  • AngryChairr

    Personally, I think Gary Oldman could pull off Poe.

  • Terminal

    I hated Combs as Poe. That episode was god awful as was most of the MOH series. I don’t see Phoenix as Poe personally.

    • The Woman In Black

      You obviously haven’t seen him in Nevermore. I’d wager big bucks you’d change your tune if you had.

      • Emy

        I agree with the Woman In Black. Combs was absolutely fantastic in it.

  • The Woman In Black

    To me, the only person who should EVER play Poe is Jeffrey Combs. Not that Joaquin wouldn’t probably do an okay job, but Combs just seems to channel Poe like he was born to play him.